John Buxton interview – Final thoughts

Posted on

John Buxton has had a long career as a professional artist. Beginning as an illustrator, he worked for some of the top corporations, book and magazine publishers. His love of American history, particularly the Colonial period, prepared him well as he transitioned into the fine arts. Although his move to fine art was not without its difficulties, his work eventually became noticed, so much so, that today he is recognized as one of America’s top historical artists.

I hope you have enjoyed this four-part interview with Buxton. In this final installment, Buxton shares some final thoughts. If you haven’t read Parts 1-3, they are easily accessed from my homepage. Just click on Blog in the menu bar and you’ll find them all there. (Click images to enlarge)


You’ve been painting professionally for over 55 years, what’s the most difficult part of painting for you today?  Yes, I have enjoyed a very long and successful career. I have been very blessed for sure. The most difficult part of painting now is finding the time. I am the sole caregiver for my sweet wife who has dementia. I want to be with her for as long as I am able to care for her increasing needs. I have been managing to sneak in a few hours of painting each day, stopping to check on her about every half hour or so. Of course this is not the most favorable way to paint, but not painting is much worse.

“How Many Beaver” – 12″ x 9″ – Oil (2005, First Place Portrait, ‘The Artist’s’ magazine. Cover art for ‘The Artist’s’ and ‘Muzzleloader’ magazines)


Do you think it’s important for an artist to concentrate on a particular genre?  Being known for my style or subject matter as an illustrator was important; I see no reason to believe it’s not the same for a fine artist. I think people, galleries, collectors, and museum shows all expect a certain thing from you, the artist. It’s especially true if you’ve garnered a following. They all expect consistency.

Most young artists will naturally try many different subjects and styles of painting; that is simply learning the trade. Collectors will buy what they consider your best work. Hopefully, it will be what you enjoy painting most because it will show in your work. As a young illustrator, I struggled to meet deadlines; I struggled to find my style; I struggled for consistency. Yes, becoming an accomplished artist is difficult, BUT, remember, YOU chose this profession. There was a reason you chose it, hopefully it brings you pleasure…enough, that you can weather the storms that will surely come.

“Eagle Feathers” – 20″ x 20″ – Oil (Best Narrative – 2021 National Oil and Acrylic Painters Society Fall International)


Congratulations for winning the “Narrative Excellence Award” in the recent National Oil and Acrylic Painters 2021 Fall Online International Exhibition; how important is it to enter art competitions?  Entering competitions can be gratifying and they can help you judge your place among your peers. It can be frustrating. It can wear on your confidence when your favorite painting is rejected. However, each judge or judging committee is totally different. It is not easy judging hundreds, if not thousands, of paintings.
Truthfully, many paintings will go unnoticed, even overlooked. Young painters should not let this setback deter their ambition. Don’t let it own you.

Who have been your greatest artistic influences? Why?  The greatest influences for me have been the older generation of illustrators because in my formative years I dreamed of someday becoming an illustrator myself.

Why are you an artist?  Why am I an artist? Hmmmmmm? I suppose it’s because I refused my aunt’s offer. She offered to pay for all of my education if I attended the North Carolina State College of Agriculture. Upon graduation, she promised to give me one of her three large farms and allow me to manage the other two as I saw fit. No one ever said I was smart.  (Ha Ha )

“Full Moon” – 12″ x 9″ – Oil (This painting has won many, many awards, but to Buxton’s surprise, it remain unsold)


What’s your definition of art?  “ART” can have a broad definition. Some say it’s in the eye of the beholder.
My query, when I left illustration…What exactly is FINE ART? So I consulted the dictionary:

Fine Art: Art that is concerned with the creation of objects of imagination and taste for their own sake without relation to the utility of the object produced
Fine: Something that is clever, ingenious, cunning, superior in character
Utility: Usefulness, power to satisfy
Hmmmm? Art without usefulness?????  Am I reading that right? Art just for art sake, I guess. Okay, from this I guess I’m still an illustrator. I have heard gallery owners say, “If it has a narrative, it’s illustration and not Fine Art.” (The interviewer believes this to be a ridiculous opinion)


How does your work reflect your personality?  When I was an illustrator, a young artist told me that my artwork was much like my personality. I had no idea what she meant because illustrations are what someone else has directed. Did she mean my personality was subservient? So now as a fine artist, I suppose I am a stuffy old history freak. Who knows?

If you were stranded on an island, what three books would you want with you?  Why am I on this island…and probably without paint, brushes or substrate? Guess I’m gonna need fire, so I’d want the biggest three paperback books for starting a fire…unless one is “How To Build A Boat”. That one I’ll burn last. If I just wanted three books to read, they would be: “The Fountainhead” by Ayn Rand; a book about J.S. Sargent, and a book of Anders Zorn paintings.

“Great Falls of the Passaic” – 56″ x 35″ – Oil (Second Place, Landscape Division, 2014 Art Renewal Center International Salon; First Place Overall/Best Figure in Landscape, 2017 Feb/Mar PleinAir Salon) This was a commissioned piece for a great collector. His only request…a stream painting. He lives only 30 minutes from this area, so we checked it out as an 18th century scene. We returned with my canoe. I got my photos but lost the canoe…smashed on the rocks.


How would you like to be remembered?  How I’m remembered, or my work, is not up to me. I have enjoyed a great run, but I would hope that my paintings, now in museums, will be equally respected for as long as those exhibited beside my pieces. I hope our family remembers that I tried to be a good father and husband, that I respected everyone I met in life and was appreciative of their friendship. Good grief, that’s depressing!

To view more of Buxton’s work


If you’ve enjoyed this blog post, please feel free to comment. Also, be sure to click that “Like” button. Thank you.

***If you would like to receive this weekly blog automatically, please complete the simple form on the bottom right of this page. To receive my monthly newsletter complete the form on the top right. Thank You.

I’m pleased to offer both of my instructional videos and book as a complete set for the first time. They may also be purchased individually. All are best sellers and include everything I’ve taught in my workshops. You can now take my oil painting workshop right in the comfort of your home, and for a lot less money than physically being present. (Click image to learn more)

For those that have purchased the book, I invite you to join our new Facebook Group – “Limited Palette Unlimited Color”. If you qualify, I hope you’ll join us. Check us out on Facebook. HERE is the link.


Want to take your painting to the next level? I can help. Click HERE to learn about my critique/mentoring programs.


John Pototschnik is an Art Renewal Center Living Master. To view his art and bio, please click HERE


Please Note - You must be logged into a Facebook account in order to write comments. We highly recommend using Google Chrome, Fire Fox, or Internet Explorer since some individuals have not been able to leave comments on the Safari browser. If you have any issues, please email me.